In a recent judgment, Mr. Justice Lawrence Mintoff found that public broadcaster PBS and its regulator, the Broadcasting Authority (BA), violated the Nationalist Party’s fundamental rights by failing to air footage from inside and outside parliament regarding a motion for a public inquiry into JP Sofia’s death on July 12, 2023.
Each entity was ordered to pay €2,000 in compensation for this breach. To prevent misrepresentation, the judge mandated a “faithful summary” of the decision to be prominently broadcast on PBS during the 8pm news bulletin within a week of the judgment becoming final.
The PN had initiated legal action, accusing PBS and the BA of perpetuating censorship against criticisms of Prime Minister Robert Abela.
Despite previous complaints to the BA, which acknowledged PBS’s reporting lapse but failed to enforce compliance, the court deemed PBS’s behavior discriminatory and violative of constitutional duties and European human rights laws.
PBS’s failure to provide valid justifications for its actions contributed to an imbalance in reporting, prompting the court’s ruling. Lawyer Paul Borg Olivier represented the PN in the case.
#MaltaDaily